Emotions are running evidently high, so I assume there may be strong reactions to this iteration of the policy as well.

Personally, I find this policy to be quite fine. It's probably not perfect, but what policy is? Especially on a first iteration. We can see what works and what doesn't with practice. We have particularly bad visibility on what the future will look like regarding to coding assistance at the moment; we're all collectively figuring it out. So let's be humble about all this.

What seems obvious to me is that nothing in this policy is specific to LLMs; it only pertains to LLMs inasmuch as LLMs make it easy to disrespect its principles. It seems like a good, decently future-proof property to me.

/Arnaud