I don’t think we should formally accept proposals that are ill-specified, in the hope that they’ll subsequently be fixed up. Pushing back to “please revise to address these points” is not a negative thing – it’s a positive thing, saying good proposal but let’s make it better.

For the record: I didn't imply otherwise (I was merely registering my acceptance provided details are filled out to the rest of the committee's satisfaction). I'm rather curious of what made my email sound like I was suggesting immediate acceptance, but I really don't want to derail this thread.