Hi all,

I've so far essentially been using the "Needs revision" label to indicate that the next concrete step has to be taken by the author, regardless of how big the changes I suggest are.

After I did this yesterday, VitWW commented, essentially saying it's only intended for cases where major rewrites are required.

From what I can tell, in past proposals, if relatively minor changes came up during the shepherding phase, sometimes "Needs revision" was used, and sometimes not.

Is there a guideline I should follow, or that you tend to follow here?

Jakob