On Wed, Jul 11, 2012 at 8:00 PM, Qi Qi <qiqi789@gmail.com> wrote:
List [] is a monad, why not for heap data. Heap data could be an instance of Monad too.

Only if you can define a meaningful semantics for it.  Lists aren't a monad because of liftIO, but because the monad pattern means something (backtracking/multiple evaluation).  What does the monad pattern mean for your heap?

I'm not saying there *isn't* one; I'm saying that you must *have* one in order to make a monad.  Monads are not simply some sneaky way to slipstream I/O into expressions; IO is just one possible monad, and many programs make heavier use of other monads such as state and reader.  And in particular, most applications of the list monad don't involve any I/O.  (Almost necessarily, since the standard ListT is actually broken but can't be fixed for backward compatibility reasons.)

--
brandon s allbery                                      allbery.b@gmail.com
wandering unix systems administrator (available)     (412) 475-9364 vm/sms