On Mon, Mar 7, 2011 at 12:39 AM, Bas van Dijk
<v.dijk.bas@gmail.com> wrote:
Sterling, Gregory, Brandon and David thanks for your suggestions.
On 6 March 2011 05:38, David Anderson <
dave@natulte.net> wrote:
> I humbly recommend doing such daemonizations from outside your program.
> Programs that daemonize on startup make it very difficult to monitor them by
> direct means, instead forcing you to rely on PID files and other mechanisms
> which may not always be available or fresh.
no stdout and stderr anymore.
> For reference, Upstart, the new PID 1 on Ubuntu and friends, has a horrible
> hack[1] built in specifically to keep track of processes that "helpfully"
> daemonize themselves, so that it can offer additional services like
> restarting crashed services or notifying the owner of a problem.
> As has been pointed out elsewhere on thread, there are plenty of standalone
> programs that implement daemonization if you end up not using service
> management software to do it for you.
I plan to run the daemon on a Ubuntu server. Do you know if Upstart is
able to daemonize a process?
It's perfectly simple. In fact, it's the default assumption of Upstart that your program doesn't daemonize, and that Upstart should help it. You have to specify if your program violates that assumption.
Here's a sample file. It specifies a service that; should run whenever the main runlevels are entered (i.e. basic system init like mounting filesystems is done, but no other guarantee); stops when the system leaves those runlevels; runs a binary that does not fork or daemonize; respawns the service if the process should die for any reason; can be manually stopped and restarted by the admin if he feels like it.
$ cat /etc/init/demo.conf
description "Demo service that doesn't daemonize by itself"
start on runlevel [2345]
stop on runlevel [!2345]
respawn
exec /path/to/binary
$ sudo start demo
demo start/running, process 27469
$ sudo stop demo
demo stop/waiting
$ sudo status demo
demo stop/waiting
$
Hope this helps. The upstart configuration format is a little sparsely documented, when I wrote scripts for it, I used the existing files in /etc/init as a rough guide.
- Dave
Regards,
Bas