RE: cvs commit: hugs98/dotnet License.net hugs98/dotnet/doc dotnet-lib.html dotnet.html examples.html hugs98/dotnet/examples/basic Env.hs Http.hs Mail.hs hugs98/dotnet/lib DotNet.hs hugs98/dotnet/lib/Syste m Array.hs ...

Just to clarify -- this is a separate toplevel namespace (mirroring the .NET Framework). Should conflicts become an issue a prefix will be added.

In what way is it a separate namespace? I haven't looked too closely, but it appears from the source and documentation that these libraries occupy the same namespace as Haskell modules, which means they overlap the existing hierarchy. Is that not the case? I can understand the desire to mirror exactly the existing .NET hierarchy, but I concur with Malcolm that the .NET base classes should really be placed under a prefix in the Haskell hierarchy. System.DotNet is fine, but I wouldn't object to taking the top-level DotNet name either. Cheers, Simon

--sigbjorn

----- Original Message ----- From: "Malcolm Wallace" To: Sent: Monday, March 03, 2003 03:30 Subject: Re: cvs commit: hugs98/dotnet License.net hugs98/dotnet/doc dotnet-lib.html dotnet.html examples.html hugs98/dotnet/examples/basic Env.hs Http.hs Mail.hs hugs98/dotnet/lib DotNet.hs hugs98/dotnet/lib/Syste m Array.hs ...

...

Sigbjorn Finne writes:

...

This commit adds interop support for the .NET platform.

Looks interesting!

However, just one minor point:

...

dotnet/lib DotNet.hs dotnet/lib/System Array.hs Console.hs DateTime.hs Enum.hs MarshalByRefObject.hs Object.hs ObjectTy.hs String.hs StringTy.hs Type.hs TypeCode.hs TypeTy.hs ValueType.hs Xml.hs dotnet/lib/System/Collections IEnumerator.hs dotnet/lib/System/IO Directory.hs DirectoryInfo.hs dotnet/lib/System/Xml XmlAttributeCollection.hs XmlNameTable.hs XmlNamedNodeMap.hs XmlNode.hs XmlNodeTy.hs XmlReader.hs

These hierarchical names look rather strange. Why "System" as a base dir? Wouldn't System.DotNet be perhaps more reasonable, ala System.Posix for instance?

Also, for example, how do these submodules compare with the more "obvious" locations:

System.Array Data.Array System.String Data.String System.Xml Text.XML

although, since they are .NET-specific, perhaps they belong down another level, e.g.

System.DotNet.Text.XML

Regards, Malcolm _______________________________________________ Cvs-hugs mailing list Cvs-hugs@haskell.org http://www.haskell.org/mailman/listinfo/cvs-hugs

_______________________________________________ Cvs-hugs mailing list Cvs-hugs@haskell.org http://www.haskell.org/mailman/listinfo/cvs-hugs