hi all, Sorry for taking so long to get back with this. I'm proposing a somewhat general way for adding 'hooks' to the GHC API, where users can override parts of the default compiling pipeline. Hooks are simply functions or actions that replace existing compiler functionality. This means that usually only one application can use a specific hook at a time. The obvious data structure to store the hooks is DynFlags. Unfortunately defining hooks in DynFlags directly would give birth to the mother of all import cycles, and it would also break the split-dll scheme on Windows. So here's the idea: - Define each hook in the module where it's exported - For each hook make a 'phantom' DataType and an instance for the Hook type familiy - Add a TypeRep based map in DynFlags [0] - For each hooked function, check for existence of a hook in DynFlags, otherwise run the default. Example: https://github.com/ghcjs/ghcjs-build/blob/master/refs/patches/ghc-ghcjs.patc... Now this approach does have some disadvantages: - No clear integration with existing plugins (I've tried adding an onLoadPlugin field to Plugin, where the Plugin could update DynFlags when it's loaded, but it was a bit messy, and plugins would not be loaded in time for some hooks, particularly what Edsko needs) - More of GHC depends on type families - Decentralized hooks definitions feel a bit messy So I'm open to suggestions for improvements (or replacements) of this scheme. I have some time the coming weeks to clean up or change the patch. We've been testing some hooks with GHCJS for a while, and so far they seem to provide what we need (but I'm going to doublecheck the coming weeks that we don't have missing functionality): - Customizations for linking JavaScript code with our own library locations [1] - Hooking into the DriverPipeline so we can use the compilation manager [2] - Desugaring customizations to remove some C-isms from the FFI code [3] - Typechecking foreign import javascript imports [4] - Override the built-in GHC.Prim so we can customize primop types [5] I think it's easy to add those for Edsko and Thomas as well. luite [0] https://github.com/ghcjs/ghcjs-build/blob/master/refs/patches/ghc-ghcjs.patc... [1] https://github.com/ghcjs/ghcjs/blob/master/src/Compiler/GhcjsHooks.hs#L44 [2] https://github.com/ghcjs/ghcjs/blob/master/src/Compiler/GhcjsHooks.hs#L192 https://github.com/ghcjs/ghcjs-build/blob/master/refs/patches/ghc-ghcjs.patc... [3] https://github.com/ghcjs/ghcjs/blob/master/src/Gen2/Foreign.hs#L67 https://github.com/ghcjs/ghcjs-build/blob/master/refs/patches/ghc-ghcjs.patc... [4] https://github.com/ghcjs/ghcjs/blob/master/src/Gen2/Foreign.hs#L68 https://github.com/ghcjs/ghcjs-build/blob/master/refs/patches/ghc-ghcjs.patc... [5] https://github.com/ghcjs/ghcjs/blob/master/src/Compiler/GhcjsHooks.hs#L191 https://github.com/ghcjs/ghcjs-build/blob/master/refs/patches/ghc-ghcjs.patc... (sorry the linked patch also contains other modifications required for GHCJS, that i'm going to submit separately)