
15 Dec
2013
15 Dec
'13
12:59 a.m.
Richard Eisenberg
Yes, I believe that's right. As far as I can figure out, these classes really *are* problematic, in that if we allowed GeneralizedNewtypeDeriving for them, there would be a way to subvert the type system. To make these derivable, we would need to be able to restrict various type parameters from taking on values that take a nominal argument. Without the ability to restrict the values in this way, there could be trouble.
I suppose it's unlikely that the roles mechanism will be extended to allow for such restriction? Cheers, - Ben