Hello all, While picking the AMP patch back up, it is almost ready to go, but I got quite a puzzling error when attempting to build 'haskeline' with the AMP changes. I don't seem to remember encountering this error before - but maybe my mind is hazy. The error in question is this: https://gist.github.com/thoughtpolice/6df4c70d8a8fb711b282 The TL;DR is that the move of `join` into base has caused a problem here. The error really speaks for itself: GND tries to derive an instance of `join` for DumbTerm, which would have the type join :: DumbTerm m (DumbTerm m a) -> DumbTerm m a and be equivalent to join for StateT. But this can't hold: DumbTerm should unwrap directly to StateT (by newtype equality) and thus the third parameter to StateT in this case is `DumbTerm m a` if you expand the types - but because this argument is Nominal, it cannot unify with 'PosixT m', which is the actual definition of DumbTerm in the first place! With a little thought, this error actually seems reasonable. But it puzzles me as to what we should do now. One thing we could do is just write the instances manually, of course. But that's a bit annoying. Another alternative (and also unfortunate) change is to leave `join` out of Monad, in which case the GND mechanism is oblivious to it and does not need to worry about deriving these cases. I am not sure how many packages depend on using GND to derive monads like StateT with Nominal arguments, but I imagine it is not totally insignificant and will essentially hurt a lot of people who may use it. Richard, I'm particularly interested to hear what you think. This one sort of snuck up! (NB: despite this, the AMP work is very close to landing in HEAD, at which point we can begin cleaning stuff up faster.) -- Regards, Austin Seipp, Haskell Consultant Well-Typed LLP, http://www.well-typed.com/