I just noticed that the discussion has been concluded and I was replying to an
old thread. I apologize for the noise.
On Wed, Feb 9, 2011 at 6:56 PM, Dan Knapp
In my one serious attempt to use git for one of my own projects, some seemingly-innocuous operation deleted a file on me and I lost a couple hours of work. I agree with the people who have said that git's documentation and semantics are highly confusing, moreso than darcs's. For example, what does it mean to "stage" a commit? Why is there an entire GUI window for this presumably-important action, and why do things I think I've committed not appear in the change history or mysteriously reverse themselves?
If ghc went to git, it wouldn't make me less likely to contribute, but I would do so by checking everything into a local darcs repo and using that to track my own changes, then letting somebody else do the work of getting them into git! Which probably would reduce the likelihood of my patch being accepted, but I consider git a complete waste of my time and have zero interest in learning to use it.
Plus, while I admire everyone's willingness to consider a VCS that isn't Haskell-based, I have to admit that there's a Haskell partisan in me. And there are real advantages to being a tight-knit community. If the GHC maintainers go to the Darcs maintainers and say "We absolutely need feature X or we will have to stop using you", the Darcs maintainers are likely to say "It'll be tough but we'll find a way to do it." But we aren't by any means the biggest project using Git, so the Git maintainers would be likely to say "That's nice, keep in touch."
Obligatory disclaimer - I've never written any code actually in GHC, although I have used the API (I am the author of direct-plugins). But I frequently read its code to clarify how things work, and I do expect that it's a near-certainty that I'll be hacking GHC itself at some point in the future.
-- Dan Knapp "An infallible method of conciliating a tiger is to allow oneself to be devoured." (Konrad Adenauer)
-- Dan Knapp "An infallible method of conciliating a tiger is to allow oneself to be devoured." (Konrad Adenauer)