john:
On Thu, Jan 25, 2007 at 07:11:55PM -0800, John Meacham wrote:
Is the binary format portable? I need the produced files to work on both 32 and 64 bit architectures and with big and little endian machines. And of course, between different versions of a compiler or different compilers.
Sorry to reply to myself, looking at the code, I see that it is. however, Ints appear to be stored as 64 bits always, this seems like a mistake. The Haskell standard only specifies Ints must have at least 30 bits of precision so programs that rely on more than that are not portable anyway. Plus, it is unlikely that any compilers ever will have Ints > 32 bits, ghc does at the moment by accident of design and it is considered a misfeature that will be fixed at some point. It would be an ugly wart to be stuck with going forward...
This was perhaps the only issue of contention during development. It was felt that those wishing to serialise precisely would use an explicit word sized type, such as Int64 or Word32, and that having things work correctly on ghc/amd64 right now was critical. If the Int/Int64 issue is resolved in the future, we can revisit this. Its fairly painless to upgrade files from one version of a Binary instance to another too (you just read in using the old 'get' method, and write back out using the new 'put' method). -- Don