On 3/5/12 5:13 PM, AntC wrote:
I've tried that ListFunc wrapping you suggest: [...] But I can't 'dig out' the H-R function and apply it (not even monomorphically):
That's because the suggestion changed it from a universal quantifier to an existential quantifier. data Exists f = forall a. Exists (f a) data Forall f = Forall (forall a. f a) With Exists, we're essentially storing a pair of the actual type 'a' and then the f a itself. We can't just pull out the f a and use it, because we don't know what 'a' is. We can bring it into scope temporarily by case matching on the Exists f, which allows us to use polymorphic functions, but we still don't actually know what it is so we can *only* use polymorphic functions. Conversely, with Forall we're storing some f a value which is in fact polymorphic in 'a'. Here, because it's polymorphic, the caller is free to choose what value of 'a' they would like the f a to use. Indeed, they can choose multiple different values of 'a' and get an f a for each of them. -- Live well, ~wren