31 Jan
2007
31 Jan
'07
1:17 p.m.
On 31/01/07, Michael T. Richter
I disagree with this part. Books written by committee lack cohesion unless they have an overbearing editor at the helm.
While that might be a problem for a 'Haskell for the Working Programmer Book' it wouldn't be a problem at all for a Cookbook style book (which I believe is what the OP was referring to here) IMO. The point of the Cookbook is that all the 'recipes' should be self contained as far as is practical, they are 'dipping in' books rather than 'read right through' books, and in this case the cohesion isn't so important. As I understand it, the Python Cookbook (published by O'Reilly) was created in large part from user contributions ( http://aspn.activestate.com/ASPN/Python/Cookbook/ ). Rob