Hi I am doing my Masters in Computing. The master's course is a conversion course for non-computing graduates. And, the only language taught in the course is Java. My undergraduate degree is in accounting. I would like to ask whether with my background I can learn Haskell and as well write a compiler for C-- in Haskell in three months for my dissertation. Is this a feasible project within the time frame? I would also like to mention that I have never written a compiler before. I would grateful if anyone can advise me on this matter. Sincerely Yours Debanjan
On Fri, 11 Apr 2003, Debanjan Chatterjee wrote:
I am doing my Masters in Computing. The master's course is a conversion course for non-computing graduates. And, the only language taught in the course is Java. My undergraduate degree is in accounting. I would like to ask whether with my background I can learn Haskell and as well write a compiler for C-- in Haskell in three months for my dissertation. Is this a feasible project within the time frame? I would also like to mention that I have never written a compiler before. I would grateful if anyone can advise me on this matter.
Although a C-- compiler in Haskell would probably be great, with your background I fear that it would take longer than three months unless you work really hard on it over that time: just getting properly into the "functional" way of thinking can take a few weeks even with a strong conventional programming background, and a good understanding of monads would be very helpful for compiler-writing. Programs always take much longer to write than you first thought in any language, especially in this case where a C-- compiler is a non-trivial project that will also have you trying out your still-young software design skills. Mind you, if your Java skills are not yet expert, it may be tough in that too, and I am sure that the people on this list will be happy to help you rapidly get to grips with Haskell and point you toward the tools that will most benefit this particular project. And, Java+Haskell probably does a lot more for your longer-term computing skills than just Java, so partly it depends what you're hoping to get out of your conversion course. I wonder if it is easier to show the correctness of Haskell code, and if that lends itself to the creation of mission-critical financial software. Even if so, persuading someone else of that may be hard. Good luck! -- Mark
Last year a student in Bolivia (Alexey Rodriguez) wrote a front end for C using our tools (cvs.cs.uu.nl) in about three months. I must say this Alexey a talented student, and few students would be able to do so in the same time. If you are interested you may contact him at alrodrig@cs.uu.nl. If you want we can also check the compiler in into our cvs, Doaitse Swierstra On vrijdag, apr 11, 2003, at 15:29 Europe/Amsterdam, Mark Carroll wrote:
On Fri, 11 Apr 2003, Debanjan Chatterjee wrote:
I am doing my Masters in Computing. The master's course is a conversion course for non-computing graduates. And, the only language taught in the course is Java. My undergraduate degree is in accounting. I would like to ask whether with my background I can learn Haskell and as well write a compiler for C-- in Haskell in three months for my dissertation. Is this a feasible project within the time frame? I would also like to mention that I have never written a compiler before. I would grateful if anyone can advise me on this matter.
Although a C-- compiler in Haskell would probably be great, with your background I fear that it would take longer than three months unless you work really hard on it over that time: just getting properly into the "functional" way of thinking can take a few weeks even with a strong conventional programming background, and a good understanding of monads would be very helpful for compiler-writing. Programs always take much longer to write than you first thought in any language, especially in this case where a C-- compiler is a non-trivial project that will also have you trying out your still-young software design skills.
Mind you, if your Java skills are not yet expert, it may be tough in that too, and I am sure that the people on this list will be happy to help you rapidly get to grips with Haskell and point you toward the tools that will most benefit this particular project. And, Java+Haskell probably does a lot more for your longer-term computing skills than just Java, so partly it depends what you're hoping to get out of your conversion course.
I wonder if it is easier to show the correctness of Haskell code, and if that lends itself to the creation of mission-critical financial software. Even if so, persuading someone else of that may be hard.
Good luck!
-- Mark
_______________________________________________ Haskell-Cafe mailing list Haskell-Cafe@haskell.org http://www.haskell.org/mailman/listinfo/haskell-cafe
participants (3)
-
Debanjan Chatterjee -
Doaitse Swierstra -
Mark Carroll