On Nov 5, 2007 2:37 PM, C.M.Brown wrote:

Hi,

I was given a quandary this evening, suppose I have the following code:

module Test1 where

import qualified Data.Map as Map

testFunction :: Ord a => Map.Map a b -> Map.Map a b -> a -> (Maybe b, Maybe b) testFunction m0 m1 k = (lookup0 k, lookup1 k) where lookup0 x = Map.lookup x m0

lookup1 x = Map.lookup x m1

This compiles and type checks fine. However, the only way I could add type signatures to lookup0 and lookup1 was to do something along the lines of this:

testFunction :: Ord a => Map.Map a b -> Map.Map a b -> a -> (Maybe b, Maybe b) testFunction m0 m1 k = (lookup0 k m0, lookup1 k m1) where lookup0 :: (Monad m, Ord a) => a -> Map.Map a b -> m b lookup0 x m0 = Map.lookup x m0

lookup1 :: (Monad m, Ord a) => a -> Map.Map a b -> m b lookup1 x m1 = Map.lookup x m1

Is there a way to give lookup0 and lookup1 explicit type signatures without passing in m0 and m1 as parameters? (So their definitions are the same as in the first example) If ghc can infer the type, surely it must be possible?

Yes, using a ghc extension of scoped type variables. In the signature of testFunction, if you explicitly quantify all your variables with forall, then they are visible in the where clause (and elsewhere in the function). Luke

On Mon, 5 Nov 2007, C.M.Brown wrote:

I was given a quandary this evening, suppose I have the following code:

Did you already try Prelude's 'asTypeOf' function?