
I recently tried the latest version of HS-PLUGINS, and it gave an error on Windows. After a bit of Googling it seemed Conal Elliot had the same problem. I reported this problem to the author. This is also (one of) the reason why I could not get YI running on Windows. Now, according to the documentation, HS-PLUGINS seems to be mainly a handy wrapper around GHC's dynamic linker and compiler. Suppose I would use GHC's dynamic linker, interpreter and compiler directly (aha "GHC as a library"); does this work on Windows, or are there known problems with these? Thanks, Peter

I recently tried the latest version of HS-PLUGINS, and it gave an error on Windows. After a bit of Googling it seemed Conal Elliot had the same problem. I reported this problem to the author. This is also (one of) the reason why I could not get YI running on Windows.
Currently I believe Conal is working on getting the latest hs-plugins to work on windows. It was recently updated to work with ghc 6.8.x (thanks Cale & co.) but there was no release as the aim is to get it working for 6.8 on both windows and linux before making an official release (currently it seems to be linux only, as I have the latest 1.1 installed from the repo below.) The latest repo for hs-plugins for 6.8 can be found at http://code.haskell.org/~dons/code/hs-plugins I'm sure Conal and others would appreciate any patches to help move it along!
Now, according to the documentation, HS-PLUGINS seems to be mainly a handy wrapper around GHC's dynamic linker and compiler. Suppose I would use GHC's dynamic linker, interpreter and compiler directly (aha "GHC as a library"); does this work on Windows, or are there known problems with these?
It's a wrapper around the RTS' linker for the most part, yes. Another half of it was interface files; GHC .hi interfaces change extremely quickly inbetween even bugfix releases (and probably changes many times even between those.) This made it hard to update for newer release of GHC. Cale ported a lot of that to using the GHC API explicitly however, which should hopefully make it more resilient to newer GHC releases. GHC as a library does work on windows and it is usable. I wrote a blog post over using the API but unfortunately where it was hosted is down as of current. It does seem however google cache'd the page nicely though if it's of any interest to you: http://www.google.com/search?q=cache:DXz9SkIg0OAJ:austin.youareinferior.net/%3Fq%3Dnode/29+using+the+GHC+API+pluggable+austin&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=1&gl=us I also wrote a library that was a small wrapper around the GHC API. The darcs repository can be found here: http://code.haskell.org/metaplug/ Note it only works on GHC 6.6.x as of right now and I've not had time to update it for 6.8. It's a sufficiently simple library though, so porting it to using 6.8 should not be hard at all (I did so on my windows box, with very few changes required.) Hope this helps! - Austin -- "It was in the days of the rains that their prayers went up, not from the fingering of knotted prayer cords or the spinning of prayer wheels, but from the great pray-machine in the monastery of Ratri, goddess of the Night." Roger Zelazny

On 2008.01.07 07:20:05 -0600, Austin Seipp
I recently tried the latest version of HS-PLUGINS, and it gave an error on Windows. After a bit of Googling it seemed Conal Elliot had the same problem. I reported this problem to the author. This is also (one of) the reason why I could not get YI running on Windows.
Currently I believe Conal is working on getting the latest hs-plugins to work on windows. It was recently updated to work with ghc 6.8.x (thanks Cale & co.) but there was no release as the aim is to get it working for 6.8 on both windows and linux before making an official release (currently it seems to be linux only, as I have the latest 1.1 installed from the repo below.) The latest repo for hs-plugins for 6.8 can be found at
http://code.haskell.org/~dons/code/hs-plugins
I'm sure Conal and others would appreciate any patches to help move it along!
Ah. That explains it. I'd been annoyed for some time now that hs-plugins was broken for so long with 6.8.x, but I had been pulling from http://www.cse.unsw.edu.au/~dons/code/hs-plugins. It's probably worth noting that the first Google hit for 'hs-plugins' is Don's pages, and that points to the old Darcs repo, http://www.cse.unsw.edu.au/~dons/hs-plugins/hs-plugins-Z-H-1.html#node_sec_1 ("Darcs repository of the latest code: darcs get --set-scripts-executable http://www.cse.unsw.edu.au/~dons/code/hs-plugins"). The second and third hits links to that page as well. Maybe the docs could be upgraded and the usual deprecation warning inserted in the old repo? -- gwern GSM Submarine E. 510 ddnp building y friends RDI JCET
participants (3)
-
Austin Seipp
-
gwern0@gmail.com
-
Peter Verswyvelen