Monadic function fails as Nothing in Maybe context but as Exception in Either context.

newer
A new case for the pointed functor...

older
[ANN] clang-pure-0.1.0.0: Pure C++...

Jeffrey Brown

30 Nov 2015 30 Nov '15

5:25 p.m.

I've written a monadic function which in a Maybe context produces a Nothing when it fails (as intended), but in an Either context produces an Exception rather than a Left. Here's a tiny demonstration. "tinyGraph" below has one Node, 0, with the label "dog". If I try to change the label at Node 0 to "cat", it works. If I try to change the label at Node 1 to "cat", it fails, because Node 1 is not in the graph. type MyGraph = Gr String String tinyGraph = mkGraph [(0, "dog")] [] :: MyGraph maybeSucceed = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 0 "cat" :: Maybe MyGraph -- == Just (mkGraph [(0,"cat")] []) maybeFail = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 1 "cat" :: Maybe MyGraph -- == Nothing eitherSucceed = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 0 "cat" :: Either String MyGraph -- == Right (mkGraph [(0,"cat")] []) eitherFail = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 1 "cat" :: Either String MyGraph -- *** Exception: Node not in Graph Here's the code: import Data.Graph.Inductive -- FGL, the Functional Graph Library gelemM :: (Monad m) => MyGraph -> Node -> m () gelemM g n = if gelem n g -- FGL's gelem function returns then return () -- True if the node is in the graph else fail "Node not in Graph" -- False otherwise replaceStringAtNode :: MyGraph -> Node -> String -> MyGraph replaceStringAtNode g n e = let (Just (a,b,c,d),g') = match n g in (a,b,e,d) & g' replaceStringAtNodeM :: (Monad m) => MyGraph -> Node -> String -> m MyGraph replaceStringAtNodeM g n s = do gelemM g n return $ replaceStringAtNode g n s -- if evaluated, the pattern match in replaceStringAtNode must succeed, -- because gelemM catches the case where n is not in the graph [1] https://github.com/JeffreyBenjaminBrown/digraphs-with-text/blob/master/test/... -- Jeffrey Benjamin Brown

Attachments:

attachment.html (text/html — 4.0 KB)

Show replies by date

Oleg Grenrus

30 Nov 30 Nov

5:34 p.m.

New subject: Monadic function fails as Nothing in Maybe context but as Exception in Either context.

Hi, Jeffrey in short: `fail` of `Either e` throws an exception (i.e. is not overriden, default implementation is `fail s = error s`) [1, 2] For `Maybe`, fail is defined as `fail _ = Nothing`; which is good default. [3] You probably want to use for example `throwError from `mtl` package [4]: gelemM :: (Monad m) => MyGraph -> Node -> m () gelemM g n = if gelem n g -- FGL's gelem function returns then return () -- True if the node is in the graph else throwError "Node not in Graph" -- False otherwise [1] https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/Data.Either.html#l... https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/Data.Either.html#l... [2] https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/GHC.Base.html#Mona... https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/GHC.Base.html#Mona... [3] https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/GHC.Base.html#line... https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/GHC.Base.html#line... [4] http://hackage.haskell.org/package/mtl-2.2.1/docs/Control-Monad-Except.html#... http://hackage.haskell.org/package/mtl-2.2.1/docs/Control-Monad-Except.html#... - Oleg

...

On 01 Dec 2015, at 00:25, Jeffrey Brown wrote:

I've written a monadic function which in a Maybe context produces a Nothing when it fails (as intended), but in an Either context produces an Exception rather than a Left.

Here's a tiny demonstration. "tinyGraph" below has one Node, 0, with the label "dog". If I try to change the label at Node 0 to "cat", it works. If I try to change the label at Node 1 to "cat", it fails, because Node 1 is not in the graph.

type MyGraph = Gr String String

tinyGraph = mkGraph [(0, "dog")] [] :: MyGraph

maybeSucceed = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 0 "cat" :: Maybe MyGraph -- == Just (mkGraph [(0,"cat")] []) maybeFail = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 1 "cat" :: Maybe MyGraph -- == Nothing

eitherSucceed = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 0 "cat" :: Either String MyGraph -- == Right (mkGraph [(0,"cat")] []) eitherFail = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 1 "cat" :: Either String MyGraph -- *** Exception: Node not in Graph

Here's the code:

import Data.Graph.Inductive -- FGL, the Functional Graph Library

gelemM :: (Monad m) => MyGraph -> Node -> m () gelemM g n = if gelem n g -- FGL's gelem function returns then return () -- True if the node is in the graph else fail "Node not in Graph" -- False otherwise

replaceStringAtNode :: MyGraph -> Node -> String -> MyGraph replaceStringAtNode g n e = let (Just (a,b,c,d),g') = match n g in (a,b,e,d) & g'

replaceStringAtNodeM :: (Monad m) => MyGraph -> Node -> String -> m MyGraph replaceStringAtNodeM g n s = do gelemM g n return $ replaceStringAtNode g n s -- if evaluated, the pattern match in replaceStringAtNode must succeed, -- because gelemM catches the case where n is not in the graph

[1] https://github.com/JeffreyBenjaminBrown/digraphs-with-text/blob/master/test/... https://github.com/JeffreyBenjaminBrown/digraphs-with-text/blob/master/test/...

-- Jeffrey Benjamin Brown _______________________________________________ Haskell-Cafe mailing list Haskell-Cafe@haskell.org http://mail.haskell.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/haskell-cafe

Oleg Grenrus

5:38 p.m.

New subject: Monadic function fails as Nothing in Maybe context but as Exception in Either context.

...

On 01 Dec 2015, at 00:34, Oleg Grenrus wrote:

Hi, Jeffrey

in short: `fail` of `Either e` throws an exception (i.e. is not overriden, default implementation is `fail s = error s`) [1, 2]

For `Maybe`, fail is defined as `fail _ = Nothing`; which is good default. [3]

You probably want to use for example `throwError from `mtl` package [4]:

I haven’t still tested it, but less wrong context is `MonadError String m`: gelemM :: (MonadError String m) => MyGraph -> Node -> m () gelemM g n = if gelem n g -- FGL's gelem function returns then return () -- True if the node is in the graph else throwError "Node not in Graph" -- False otherwise

...

[1] https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/Data.Either.html#l... https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/Data.Either.html#l... [2] https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/GHC.Base.html#Mona... https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/GHC.Base.html#Mona... [3] https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/GHC.Base.html#line... https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/GHC.Base.html#line... [4] http://hackage.haskell.org/package/mtl-2.2.1/docs/Control-Monad-Except.html#... http://hackage.haskell.org/package/mtl-2.2.1/docs/Control-Monad-Except.html#...

- Oleg

...
On 01 Dec 2015, at 00:25, Jeffrey Brown mailto:jeffbrown.the@gmail.com> wrote:

I've written a monadic function which in a Maybe context produces a Nothing when it fails (as intended), but in an Either context produces an Exception rather than a Left.

Here's a tiny demonstration. "tinyGraph" below has one Node, 0, with the label "dog". If I try to change the label at Node 0 to "cat", it works. If I try to change the label at Node 1 to "cat", it fails, because Node 1 is not in the graph.

type MyGraph = Gr String String

tinyGraph = mkGraph [(0, "dog")] [] :: MyGraph

maybeSucceed = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 0 "cat" :: Maybe MyGraph -- == Just (mkGraph [(0,"cat")] []) maybeFail = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 1 "cat" :: Maybe MyGraph -- == Nothing

eitherSucceed = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 0 "cat" :: Either String MyGraph -- == Right (mkGraph [(0,"cat")] []) eitherFail = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 1 "cat" :: Either String MyGraph -- *** Exception: Node not in Graph

Here's the code:

import Data.Graph.Inductive -- FGL, the Functional Graph Library

gelemM :: (Monad m) => MyGraph -> Node -> m () gelemM g n = if gelem n g -- FGL's gelem function returns then return () -- True if the node is in the graph else fail "Node not in Graph" -- False otherwise

replaceStringAtNode :: MyGraph -> Node -> String -> MyGraph replaceStringAtNode g n e = let (Just (a,b,c,d),g') = match n g in (a,b,e,d) & g'

replaceStringAtNodeM :: (Monad m) => MyGraph -> Node -> String -> m MyGraph replaceStringAtNodeM g n s = do gelemM g n return $ replaceStringAtNode g n s -- if evaluated, the pattern match in replaceStringAtNode must succeed, -- because gelemM catches the case where n is not in the graph

[1] https://github.com/JeffreyBenjaminBrown/digraphs-with-text/blob/master/test/... https://github.com/JeffreyBenjaminBrown/digraphs-with-text/blob/master/test/...

-- Jeffrey Benjamin Brown _______________________________________________ Haskell-Cafe mailing list Haskell-Cafe@haskell.org mailto:Haskell-Cafe@haskell.org http://mail.haskell.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/haskell-cafe

_______________________________________________ Haskell-Cafe mailing list Haskell-Cafe@haskell.org http://mail.haskell.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/haskell-cafe

Jeffrey Brown

9:18 p.m.

Oleg's suggestion works! I just had to add these two lines in order to use it: {-# LANGUAGE FlexibleContexts #-} import Control.Monad.Except -- mtl library Thanks, everybody! On Mon, Nov 30, 2015 at 2:38 PM, Oleg Grenrus wrote:

...

On 01 Dec 2015, at 00:34, Oleg Grenrus wrote:

Hi, Jeffrey

in short: `fail` of `Either e` throws an exception (i.e. is not overriden, default implementation is `fail s = error s`) [1, 2]

For `Maybe`, fail is defined as `fail _ = Nothing`; which is good default. [3]

You probably want to use for example `throwError from `mtl` package [4]:

I haven’t still tested it, but less wrong context is `MonadError String m`:

gelemM :: (MonadError String m) => MyGraph -> Node -> m () gelemM g n = if gelem n g -- FGL's gelem function returns then return () -- True if the node is in the graph else throwError "Node not in Graph" -- False otherwise

[1] https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/Data.Either.html#l... [2] https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/GHC.Base.html#Mona... [3] https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/GHC.Base.html#line... [4] http://hackage.haskell.org/package/mtl-2.2.1/docs/Control-Monad-Except.html#...

- Oleg

On 01 Dec 2015, at 00:25, Jeffrey Brown wrote:

I've written a monadic function which in a Maybe context produces a Nothing when it fails (as intended), but in an Either context produces an Exception rather than a Left.

Here's a tiny demonstration. "tinyGraph" below has one Node, 0, with the label "dog". If I try to change the label at Node 0 to "cat", it works. If I try to change the label at Node 1 to "cat", it fails, because Node 1 is not in the graph.

type MyGraph = Gr String String

tinyGraph = mkGraph [(0, "dog")] [] :: MyGraph

maybeSucceed = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 0 "cat" :: Maybe MyGraph -- == Just (mkGraph [(0,"cat")] []) maybeFail = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 1 "cat" :: Maybe MyGraph -- == Nothing

eitherSucceed = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 0 "cat" :: Either String MyGraph -- == Right (mkGraph [(0,"cat")] []) eitherFail = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 1 "cat" :: Either String MyGraph -- *** Exception: Node not in Graph

Here's the code:

import Data.Graph.Inductive -- FGL, the Functional Graph Library

gelemM :: (Monad m) => MyGraph -> Node -> m () gelemM g n = if gelem n g -- FGL's gelem function returns then return () -- True if the node is in the graph else fail "Node not in Graph" -- False otherwise

replaceStringAtNode :: MyGraph -> Node -> String -> MyGraph replaceStringAtNode g n e = let (Just (a,b,c,d),g') = match n g in (a,b,e,d) & g'

replaceStringAtNodeM :: (Monad m) => MyGraph -> Node -> String -> m MyGraph replaceStringAtNodeM g n s = do gelemM g n return $ replaceStringAtNode g n s -- if evaluated, the pattern match in replaceStringAtNode must succeed, -- because gelemM catches the case where n is not in the graph

[1] https://github.com/JeffreyBenjaminBrown/digraphs-with-text/blob/master/test/...

-- Jeffrey Benjamin Brown _______________________________________________ Haskell-Cafe mailing list Haskell-Cafe@haskell.org http://mail.haskell.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/haskell-cafe

_______________________________________________ Haskell-Cafe mailing list Haskell-Cafe@haskell.org http://mail.haskell.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/haskell-cafe

-- Jeffrey Benjamin Brown

Jeffrey Brown

1 Dec 1 Dec

1:44 p.m.

I spoke too soon; I'm seeing the same problem with MonadError. Prelude> :set -XFlexibleContexts Prelude> import Control.Monad.Except Prelude Control.Monad.Except> let f = (fail "be Left!" :: (MonadError String m) => m ()) Loading package transformers-0.4.2.0 ... linking ... done. Loading package mtl-2.2.1 ... linking ... done. Prelude Control.Monad.Except> f :: Either String () *** Exception: be Left! Prelude Control.Monad.Except> On Mon, Nov 30, 2015 at 6:18 PM, Jeffrey Brown wrote:

...

Oleg's suggestion works! I just had to add these two lines in order to use it:

{-# LANGUAGE FlexibleContexts #-} import Control.Monad.Except -- mtl library

Thanks, everybody!

On Mon, Nov 30, 2015 at 2:38 PM, Oleg Grenrus wrote:

...
On 01 Dec 2015, at 00:34, Oleg Grenrus wrote:

Hi, Jeffrey

in short: `fail` of `Either e` throws an exception (i.e. is not overriden, default implementation is `fail s = error s`) [1, 2]

For `Maybe`, fail is defined as `fail _ = Nothing`; which is good default. [3]

You probably want to use for example `throwError from `mtl` package [4]:

I haven’t still tested it, but less wrong context is `MonadError String m`:

gelemM :: (MonadError String m) => MyGraph -> Node -> m () gelemM g n = if gelem n g -- FGL's gelem function returns then return () -- True if the node is in the graph else throwError "Node not in Graph" -- False otherwise

[1] https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/Data.Either.html#l... [2] https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/GHC.Base.html#Mona... [3] https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/GHC.Base.html#line... [4] http://hackage.haskell.org/package/mtl-2.2.1/docs/Control-Monad-Except.html#...

- Oleg

On 01 Dec 2015, at 00:25, Jeffrey Brown wrote:

I've written a monadic function which in a Maybe context produces a Nothing when it fails (as intended), but in an Either context produces an Exception rather than a Left.

Here's a tiny demonstration. "tinyGraph" below has one Node, 0, with the label "dog". If I try to change the label at Node 0 to "cat", it works. If I try to change the label at Node 1 to "cat", it fails, because Node 1 is not in the graph.

type MyGraph = Gr String String

tinyGraph = mkGraph [(0, "dog")] [] :: MyGraph

maybeSucceed = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 0 "cat" :: Maybe MyGraph -- == Just (mkGraph [(0,"cat")] []) maybeFail = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 1 "cat" :: Maybe MyGraph -- == Nothing

eitherSucceed = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 0 "cat" :: Either String MyGraph -- == Right (mkGraph [(0,"cat")] []) eitherFail = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 1 "cat" :: Either String MyGraph -- *** Exception: Node not in Graph

Here's the code:

import Data.Graph.Inductive -- FGL, the Functional Graph Library

gelemM :: (Monad m) => MyGraph -> Node -> m () gelemM g n = if gelem n g -- FGL's gelem function returns then return () -- True if the node is in the graph else fail "Node not in Graph" -- False otherwise

replaceStringAtNode :: MyGraph -> Node -> String -> MyGraph replaceStringAtNode g n e = let (Just (a,b,c,d),g') = match n g in (a,b,e,d) & g'

replaceStringAtNodeM :: (Monad m) => MyGraph -> Node -> String -> m MyGraph replaceStringAtNodeM g n s = do gelemM g n return $ replaceStringAtNode g n s -- if evaluated, the pattern match in replaceStringAtNode must succeed, -- because gelemM catches the case where n is not in the graph

[1] https://github.com/JeffreyBenjaminBrown/digraphs-with-text/blob/master/test/...

-- Jeffrey Benjamin Brown _______________________________________________ Haskell-Cafe mailing list Haskell-Cafe@haskell.org http://mail.haskell.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/haskell-cafe

_______________________________________________ Haskell-Cafe mailing list Haskell-Cafe@haskell.org http://mail.haskell.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/haskell-cafe

-- Jeffrey Benjamin Brown

-- Jeffrey Benjamin Brown

Oleg Grenrus

1:46 p.m.

New subject: Monadic function fails as Nothing in Maybe context but as Exception in Either context.

Use `throwError`, not `fail`. :) Forget `fail`. Luckily we are taking it out of `Monad`. - Oleg

...

On 01 Dec 2015, at 20:44, Jeffrey Brown wrote:

I spoke too soon; I'm seeing the same problem with MonadError.

Prelude> :set -XFlexibleContexts Prelude> import Control.Monad.Except Prelude Control.Monad.Except> let f = (fail "be Left!" :: (MonadError String m) => m ()) Loading package transformers-0.4.2.0 ... linking ... done. Loading package mtl-2.2.1 ... linking ... done. Prelude Control.Monad.Except> f :: Either String () *** Exception: be Left! Prelude Control.Monad.Except>

On Mon, Nov 30, 2015 at 6:18 PM, Jeffrey Brown mailto:jeffbrown.the@gmail.com> wrote: Oleg's suggestion works! I just had to add these two lines in order to use it:

{-# LANGUAGE FlexibleContexts #-} import Control.Monad.Except -- mtl library

Thanks, everybody!

On Mon, Nov 30, 2015 at 2:38 PM, Oleg Grenrus mailto:oleg.grenrus@iki.fi> wrote:

...
On 01 Dec 2015, at 00:34, Oleg Grenrus mailto:oleg.grenrus@iki.fi> wrote:

Hi, Jeffrey

in short: `fail` of `Either e` throws an exception (i.e. is not overriden, default implementation is `fail s = error s`) [1, 2]

For `Maybe`, fail is defined as `fail _ = Nothing`; which is good default. [3]

You probably want to use for example `throwError from `mtl` package [4]:

I haven’t still tested it, but less wrong context is `MonadError String m`:

gelemM :: (MonadError String m) => MyGraph -> Node -> m () gelemM g n = if gelem n g -- FGL's gelem function returns then return () -- True if the node is in the graph else throwError "Node not in Graph" -- False otherwise

...
[1] https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/Data.Either.html#l... https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/Data.Either.html#l... [2] https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/GHC.Base.html#Mona... https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/GHC.Base.html#Mona... [3] https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/GHC.Base.html#line... https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/GHC.Base.html#line... [4] http://hackage.haskell.org/package/mtl-2.2.1/docs/Control-Monad-Except.html#... http://hackage.haskell.org/package/mtl-2.2.1/docs/Control-Monad-Except.html#...

- Oleg

...
On 01 Dec 2015, at 00:25, Jeffrey Brown mailto:jeffbrown.the@gmail.com> wrote:

I've written a monadic function which in a Maybe context produces a Nothing when it fails (as intended), but in an Either context produces an Exception rather than a Left.

Here's a tiny demonstration. "tinyGraph" below has one Node, 0, with the label "dog". If I try to change the label at Node 0 to "cat", it works. If I try to change the label at Node 1 to "cat", it fails, because Node 1 is not in the graph.

type MyGraph = Gr String String

tinyGraph = mkGraph [(0, "dog")] [] :: MyGraph

maybeSucceed = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 0 "cat" :: Maybe MyGraph -- == Just (mkGraph [(0,"cat")] []) maybeFail = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 1 "cat" :: Maybe MyGraph -- == Nothing

eitherSucceed = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 0 "cat" :: Either String MyGraph -- == Right (mkGraph [(0,"cat")] []) eitherFail = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 1 "cat" :: Either String MyGraph -- *** Exception: Node not in Graph

Here's the code:

import Data.Graph.Inductive -- FGL, the Functional Graph Library

gelemM :: (Monad m) => MyGraph -> Node -> m () gelemM g n = if gelem n g -- FGL's gelem function returns then return () -- True if the node is in the graph else fail "Node not in Graph" -- False otherwise

replaceStringAtNode :: MyGraph -> Node -> String -> MyGraph replaceStringAtNode g n e = let (Just (a,b,c,d),g') = match n g in (a,b,e,d) & g'

replaceStringAtNodeM :: (Monad m) => MyGraph -> Node -> String -> m MyGraph replaceStringAtNodeM g n s = do gelemM g n return $ replaceStringAtNode g n s -- if evaluated, the pattern match in replaceStringAtNode must succeed, -- because gelemM catches the case where n is not in the graph

[1] https://github.com/JeffreyBenjaminBrown/digraphs-with-text/blob/master/test/... https://github.com/JeffreyBenjaminBrown/digraphs-with-text/blob/master/test/...

-- Jeffrey Benjamin Brown _______________________________________________ Haskell-Cafe mailing list Haskell-Cafe@haskell.org mailto:Haskell-Cafe@haskell.org http://mail.haskell.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/haskell-cafe http://mail.haskell.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/haskell-cafe

_______________________________________________ Haskell-Cafe mailing list Haskell-Cafe@haskell.org mailto:Haskell-Cafe@haskell.org http://mail.haskell.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/haskell-cafe http://mail.haskell.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/haskell-cafe

-- Jeffrey Benjamin Brown

-- Jeffrey Benjamin Brown

Jeffrey Brown

1:48 p.m.

Right! That's what I was doing when I got it to work and then I forgot. I will correct the habit. Sorry for the annoyance! On Tue, Dec 1, 2015 at 10:46 AM, Oleg Grenrus wrote:

...

Use `throwError`, not `fail`. :)

Forget `fail`. Luckily we are taking it out of `Monad`.

- Oleg

On 01 Dec 2015, at 20:44, Jeffrey Brown wrote:

I spoke too soon; I'm seeing the same problem with MonadError.

Prelude> :set -XFlexibleContexts Prelude> import Control.Monad.Except Prelude Control.Monad.Except> let f = (fail "be Left!" :: (MonadError String m) => m ()) Loading package transformers-0.4.2.0 ... linking ... done. Loading package mtl-2.2.1 ... linking ... done. Prelude Control.Monad.Except> f :: Either String () *** Exception: be Left! Prelude Control.Monad.Except>

On Mon, Nov 30, 2015 at 6:18 PM, Jeffrey Brown wrote:

...
Oleg's suggestion works! I just had to add these two lines in order to use it:

{-# LANGUAGE FlexibleContexts #-} import Control.Monad.Except -- mtl library

Thanks, everybody!

On Mon, Nov 30, 2015 at 2:38 PM, Oleg Grenrus wrote:

...
On 01 Dec 2015, at 00:34, Oleg Grenrus wrote:

Hi, Jeffrey

in short: `fail` of `Either e` throws an exception (i.e. is not overriden, default implementation is `fail s = error s`) [1, 2]

For `Maybe`, fail is defined as `fail _ = Nothing`; which is good default. [3]

You probably want to use for example `throwError from `mtl` package [4]:

I haven’t still tested it, but less wrong context is `MonadError String m`:

gelemM :: (MonadError String m) => MyGraph -> Node -> m () gelemM g n = if gelem n g -- FGL's gelem function returns then return () -- True if the node is in the graph else throwError "Node not in Graph" -- False otherwise

[1] https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/Data.Either.html#l... [2] https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/GHC.Base.html#Mona... [3] https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.8.1.0/docs/src/GHC.Base.html#line... [4] http://hackage.haskell.org/package/mtl-2.2.1/docs/Control-Monad-Except.html#...

- Oleg

On 01 Dec 2015, at 00:25, Jeffrey Brown wrote:

I've written a monadic function which in a Maybe context produces a Nothing when it fails (as intended), but in an Either context produces an Exception rather than a Left.

Here's a tiny demonstration. "tinyGraph" below has one Node, 0, with the label "dog". If I try to change the label at Node 0 to "cat", it works. If I try to change the label at Node 1 to "cat", it fails, because Node 1 is not in the graph.

type MyGraph = Gr String String

tinyGraph = mkGraph [(0, "dog")] [] :: MyGraph

maybeSucceed = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 0 "cat" :: Maybe MyGraph -- == Just (mkGraph [(0,"cat")] []) maybeFail = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 1 "cat" :: Maybe MyGraph -- == Nothing

eitherSucceed = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 0 "cat" :: Either String MyGraph -- == Right (mkGraph [(0,"cat")] []) eitherFail = replaceStringAtNodeM tinyGraph 1 "cat" :: Either String MyGraph -- *** Exception: Node not in Graph

Here's the code:

import Data.Graph.Inductive -- FGL, the Functional Graph Library

gelemM :: (Monad m) => MyGraph -> Node -> m () gelemM g n = if gelem n g -- FGL's gelem function returns then return () -- True if the node is in the graph else fail "Node not in Graph" -- False otherwise

replaceStringAtNode :: MyGraph -> Node -> String -> MyGraph replaceStringAtNode g n e = let (Just (a,b,c,d),g') = match n g in (a,b,e,d) & g'

replaceStringAtNodeM :: (Monad m) => MyGraph -> Node -> String -> m MyGraph replaceStringAtNodeM g n s = do gelemM g n return $ replaceStringAtNode g n s -- if evaluated, the pattern match in replaceStringAtNode must succeed, -- because gelemM catches the case where n is not in the graph

[1] https://github.com/JeffreyBenjaminBrown/digraphs-with-text/blob/master/test/...

-- Jeffrey Benjamin Brown _______________________________________________ Haskell-Cafe mailing list Haskell-Cafe@haskell.org http://mail.haskell.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/haskell-cafe

_______________________________________________ Haskell-Cafe mailing list Haskell-Cafe@haskell.org http://mail.haskell.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/haskell-cafe

-- Jeffrey Benjamin Brown

-- Jeffrey Benjamin Brown

-- Jeffrey Benjamin Brown

William Yager

3:34 p.m.

Shouldn't that be "throwError", not "fail"? --Will On Tue, Dec 1, 2015 at 12:44 PM, Jeffrey Brown wrote:

...

I spoke too soon; I'm seeing the same problem with MonadError.

Prelude> :set -XFlexibleContexts Prelude> import Control.Monad.Except Prelude Control.Monad.Except> let f = (fail "be Left!" :: (MonadError String m) => m ()) Loading package transformers-0.4.2.0 ... linking ... done. Loading package mtl-2.2.1 ... linking ... done. Prelude Control.Monad.Except> f :: Either String () *** Exception: be Left! Prelude Control.Monad.Except>

William Yager

3:35 p.m.

Oops, disregard that. Other responses didn't show up for some reason. On Tue, Dec 1, 2015 at 2:34 PM, William Yager wrote:

...

Shouldn't that be "throwError", not "fail"?

--Will

On Tue, Dec 1, 2015 at 12:44 PM, Jeffrey Brown wrote:

...
I spoke too soon; I'm seeing the same problem with MonadError.

Prelude> :set -XFlexibleContexts Prelude> import Control.Monad.Except Prelude Control.Monad.Except> let f = (fail "be Left!" :: (MonadError String m) => m ()) Loading package transformers-0.4.2.0 ... linking ... done. Loading package mtl-2.2.1 ... linking ... done. Prelude Control.Monad.Except> f :: Either String () *** Exception: be Left! Prelude Control.Monad.Except>

Michael Walker

30 Nov 30 Nov

5:36 p.m.

On Mon, 30 Nov 2015 14:25:49 -0800 Jeffrey Brown wrote:

...

I've written a monadic function which in a Maybe context produces a Nothing when it fails (as intended), but in an Either context produces an Exception rather than a Left.

The Monad instance for (Either e) uses the default definition of 'fail', which is to throw an exception: instance Monad (Either e) where return = Right Left l >>= _ = Left l Right r >>= k = k r In general, 'Left' can't be used because that would only type check for (Either String), but the Monad instance is more general than that. -- Michael Walker (http://www.barrucadu.co.uk)

Bryan Richter

5:40 p.m.

On Mon, Nov 30, 2015 at 02:25:49PM -0800, Jeffrey Brown wrote:

...

I've written a monadic function which in a Maybe context produces a Nothing when it fails (as intended), but in an Either context produces an Exception rather than a Left.

The Maybe instance for Monad overrides fail to be Nothing, but Either instance does not. The default definition for fail is error. The Except type has the behavior you are looking for, I believe — but you may be better off avoiding the use of fail to begin with. :) Except/ExceptT: http://haddock.stackage.org/lts-3.16/transformers-0.4.2.0/Control-Monad-Tran... Also recommended for all your error-ful needs: http://haddock.stackage.org/lts-3.16/errors-2.0.1/Control-Error.html

3458

Age (days ago)

3459

Last active (days ago)

List overview

Download

10 comments

5 participants

participants (5)

Bryan Richter
Jeffrey Brown
Michael Walker
Oleg Grenrus
William Yager