Re: [Haskell-cafe] Darcs home page updated

On Mon, 30 Apr 2012 12:27:57 -0700, Simon Michael

Thanks for the feedback Paul (and Michael), all such is very useful. Maybe I'll try Django-green... :)
- there is a video right on the first page, good ! Unfortunatly, it is not showing darcs but its cousin. Also, the title is "why do we continue to develop ... [camp]", which isn't the most positive approach one can expect on a start page
It does discuss both camp and darcs. I meant to say the following: I was happy to be able to use Ian Lynagh's video, which I have always felt strikes a very good tone - technical, concise, grounded and energising. I like listening to it. Thanks Ian! Also, there isn't a lot out there to work with. Please let me know if I'm missing something else good.
- the compact tutorial is great, I love it. It deserves more poish. For inspiration, one can have a look at this website for example :
Good to hear, I have scheduled more polish.
- underlined links looks a bit 90's. You can add a simple css rule to choose an other color and remove the underline (though it is good practice to set it on mouseover)
Oh I thought underline had come back in. Ok done. A few more notes trimmed from the original mail: - I've tried to emphasise the relative simplicity Darcs offers. I think this is a true strength and our biggest value proposition. (Aside: I think Haskell is another true strength, but a less obvious one, currently not mentioned.) - You may notice my very swift description of patch dependencies. Though we are used to thinking of patch deps as painful, I think the text is a fair and accurate high-level description for newcomers. The video gives a little more insight. - Like some other sites (I liked Mercurial's best), we have quick start examples right on the front page. This grew a bit long, but how handy to be able to jump to darcs.net and instantly see how to get stuff done.. and its basically *all you need to know* to use Darcs, correct me if I'm wrong. - The colours are a bit anaemic. Needs more red and dark tones. The dark pres I tried gave less contrast.. - I use and occasionally hack on Alex Suraci's darcsden repo-hosting app. You can see my dev repo and changes at http://joyful.com/darcsden/simon/darcs-sm , and you might even be able to register, fork, show previews and send pull requests there - testers welcome. Perhaps one day this could be on darcs.net, or a reliable funded darcsden.com, or something. Best - Simon

Simon> It does discuss both camp and darcs. I meant to say the following: Simon> I was happy to be able to use Ian Lynagh's video, which I have always Simon> felt strikes a very good tone - technical, concise, grounded and Simon> energising. I like listening to it. Thanks Ian! Indeed, the form, duration and pace are all very good in this video. However, if I understand correctly, your initiative mainly targets potential newcomers. I am not sure they will understand the connection here, and they will quickly ask how to display the patches DAG in darcs. Also, from a communication POV, the title of the video does not match well with the date of the video ( we are on darcs.net and the video is "why we continue to develop Camp" and is from 2008 :] ) I don't dismiss the great work on this camp video itself. It is just that if some darcs user has time to make a 2012 darcs video (name hit : "darcs vs git"), based on the same idea, that would probably be more suited for darcs website. regards, -- Paul
participants (2)
-
Paul R
-
Simon Michael