On 2/16/06, Henrik Nilsson
Conor and I discussed this over lunch.
Specifically, we talked about whether the right hand side of a pattern synonym would be any Haskell pattern (including "_", "~", possibly "!"), or restricted to the intersection between the patterns and terms, as Conor propose that pattern synonyms also be used for construction.
By adopting some simple conventions, like replacing "_" by "undefined" when a synonym is used as a term for construction, it is clear that one can be a bit more liberal than a strict intersection between the pattern and current expression syntax.
I would speak against this. I like the idea of pattern synonyms, but I think they should be just that - pattern synonyms, and not try to mix in expressions as well. With the current (H98) pattern situation, it *might* be possible to tweak things so that all patterns have an expressional meaning (e.g. "_" as "undefined"), but 1) it would be fairly construed in many cases, and 2) it would complicate making extensions to the pattern matching facility. (Shameless plug:) In particular I'm thinking about our extension HaRP [1] that adds regular expressions to pattern matching over lists. The ability to define pattern synonyms would be really useful in conjunction with HaRP, but if those patterns are required to also have an expressional meaning it would make things fairly complicated, not to say impossible. Instead I would like to propose an extension to the proposed extension in another direction: Adding in (pattern) guards. Consider patterns like IsSpace x = x | isSpace x Last x = xs | x <- last xs This would in particular go well together with HaRP, where you in some cases need guards to be inlined, e.g. words [ (IsSpace _)*!, (/ xs@:(_*), (IsSpace _)*! /)* ] = xs Btw, why not consider adding regular patterns a la HaRP to Haskell'? :-) (Disclaimer: I'm not really serious, like Lennart I don't really feel that any of this has any place in Haskell'. But as for the future beyond that, I am serious.) [1] http://www.cs.chalmers.se/~d00nibro/harp