Re: #2309: containers: specialize functions that fail in a Monad to Maybe

+1 in favour too.

This is Haskell, and as such, program crashable effects should not be the default, whenever possible.

Indeed!

Regarding support for older programs relying on IO effects here, deprecated versions with the old type would be a good concession to backwards compatibility, or adding a lifter of,

... => Maybe a -> m a

fromJustM?

No information is lost, because in each case there is a single failure mode.

Also, they call fail with a String, which pretty much means there is no information beyond debugging hints present anyway. If you wanted to indicate failure either added information, Monad.fail, Maybe or Either String would not be the way to do it,. Thanks Neil