On 2014-05-10 19:15, Edward Kmett wrote:
I just want to say that I personally find this thread an the the similar "sky is falling" discussion about Lennart being on vacation for 2 weeks to be alarming and far far too hasty.
Please consider the implications of such a 'shoot first' policy on participation within the community.
[--snip--] I've snipped most of it, but +1000 to everything you said! Some people like really long vacations *away from computers*, some people like to batch things up, etc. Trusted users bumping some version bounds is one thing, but taking over maintainership just because someone is AFK for 4 days? That's insane! (If such a policy were in effect, I'm pretty sure GHC itself could have already been taken over by someone other than SPJ just because he was on vacation or otherwise indisposed.) Likewise for the requirement for "backup maintainers" to avoid such problems. Although my Hackage packages are all (happilfy for me) towards the leaves of the dependency tree, I don't actually know anyone that I trust sufficiently and who is competent enough in Haskell to be a backup for maintainer for any of my packages. I imagine that the people who have packages with lots of reverse dependencies are even more hard pressed to find suitable "backups". So, yeah. +1000 to what ekmett said. Regards,