On April 19, 2011 12:22:39 Maciej Marcin Piechotka wrote:
On Tue, 2011-04-19 at 17:29 +0200, Henning Thielemann wrote:
Is it common to make a type an instance of both Arrow and Functor type class? If a type is both instance of Arrow and Functor, would you expect that fmap = (^<<) ? If yes, how about adding this as expected law to the Control.Arrow documentation? Same question for Applicative functors and liftA2 (,) = (&&&). (Btw. Control.Arrow haddock documentation does not mention any Arrow law so far.)
I believe reading in some paper/monad reader article that Arrow is equivalent to Category that is Functor.
I think that is actually an Applicative Category (just a bit more power) valid for all source types. The first I was exposed to this idea was Patai's blog. If you know of another source, I would like to know as I've been working to ensure the laws follow from the parametricity and write up a little summary. Anyway, assuming the laws are all okay, the applicative side of it is especially clear if you look at an alternative definition for applicative class Functor m => Applicative' m where order :: m a -> m a -> m (a,b) This alternative definition puts emphasis on the fundamental operation of pairwise ordering. The order aspect is usually a bit hidden by the fact that (<*>) does it when sticking them into a closure. f <*> x = fmap ap $ f `order` x where ap (f,x) = f x Thinking of the fundamental Applicative operation as ordering really reveals why it (and Monad) is so useful for IO. An ordering combinator is the critical element required for determinism in the face of side effects. All the arrow stuff falls out pretty easy given this definition. Let ''' be used to indicate the standard operations on underlying category. id' = Control.Category.id (.') = (Control.Category..) arr f = fmap f id' fst' = arr fst snd' = arr snd first f = (f .' fst') `order` snd' second g = fst' `order` (g .' snd') f *** g = (f .' fst') `order` (g .' snd') f &&& g = f `order` g The extended Arrow functionality is similarly obtained from extended Applicative functionality. For example, ArrowApply comes from Monad app' = join $ arr (.' snd') .' fst' ArrowLoop from MonadFix loop' f = fst' .' loop'' (f .' arr' (second snd)) where loop'' f = mfix (\y -> f .' arr' (,y)) and so on. Cheers! -Tyson PS: Note that "second snd = \(x,(_,y)) -> (x,y)" as (->) is an Arrow.