I'd like to +1 everything said here, and say as an observer it's strange to have the decision made privately and announced here as a fait accompli. Another thing to note about email is that it's decentralized and has (and presumably always will have) plenty of clients and tools. I've seen discussions linking to email conversations that are significantly older than GitHub itself - there's value to archives of old discussions. If GitHub folds or starts charging money or redesigns its site in an unhelpful way, all discussion would be lost or made less accessible. Whereas mailing list archives can jump to new hosts indefinitely. Tom On Sat, Sep 12, 2020 at 03:44:10PM +0200, Bertram Felgenhauer via Libraries wrote:
Carter Schonwald wrote:
Are you sure about this approach? I think you need to start with an open discussion , And have a open ended thread about ideas for how to improve how we do things.
I totally agree with this, though fleshing out ideas in a smaller forum first is helpful.
An important consideration here is that there are several types of stakeholders in the library proposal process, including
* the CLC members, who ultimately decide on core library changes; * proponents ("authors"), who originate proposals for such changes; and * observers ("the wider Haskell community"), users of the core libraries who want to keep track of upcoming library changes and chime in when a proposal affects their own uses of a library.
I suspect that the observers are a silent majority, and that a mailing list with public archives is close to optimal for them. (I consider myself an observer and I do like the mailing list for precisely this reason. But I also grew up with mailing lists, not forums, so I'm surely biased here.)
In any case I think that any change to the library proposal process should cater to all three types of stakeholders (and possibly others I have failed to think of). In its current form, I believe
https://github.com/haskell-core/core-libraries-proposals
fails to do that for observers.
Cheers,
Bertram _______________________________________________ Libraries mailing list Libraries@haskell.org http://mail.haskell.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/libraries