On 10 January 2005 21:26, Dominic Steinitz wrote:
Thanks for this. I'd forgotten about the document describing the hierarchy. The Codec.Utils exports:
type Octet = Word8 msb :: Int fromTwosComp :: Integral a => [Octet] -> a toOctets :: Integral a => a -> a -> [Octet] fromOctets :: Num a => a -> [Octet] -> a i2osp :: Integral a => Int -> a -> [Octet]
Thinking about it, i2osp should go in Codec.Encryption.RSA as it's specific to RSA.
I'm not clear about the rest. How about Codec.Integral for toOctets, fromOctets and fromTwosComp? I could probably live without Octet (although quite a few standards are defined using the term octet) but I find myself needing msb (most significant bit) in quite a few places. Where would that go?
If these really are general codec utilities, applicable to multiple codecs, then Codec.Utils is fine. There's no point trying too hard to categorise things.
Whilst on the subject, why is BER in Network? BER is one of many encodings for ASN.1 and use of BER is not limited to networks; it is used heavily in cryptography, for example, in PKCS#8 and X.509. I'd suggest Codec.ASN1.BER, Codec.ASN1.TLV for the functions that take octets and turn them into Tags, Lengths and Values and Codec.ASN1.ASN1 for real ASN.1 types and functions.
Ok, I'll add these. But Codec.ASN1.ASN1 looks a bit strange - why not just use Codec.ASN1?
Furthermore, if I follow the hierarchy for the existing cryptography library then I would end up with Data.Digest for MD5 and SHA-1. What would the package name for these be? Digest? What should the package name be for DES, AES, Blowfish and RSA be? Still crypto or Encryption?
You can choose any package names you like, as long as they're unique. Package names have no relationship to module names. When Hackage is up and running, you'll easily be able to find a new unique package name (for now, just pick one). Cheers, Simon
On Tuesday 11 Jan 2005 10:35 am, Simon Marlow wrote:
On 10 January 2005 21:26, Dominic Steinitz wrote:
Thanks for this. I'd forgotten about the document describing the hierarchy. The Codec.Utils exports:
type Octet = Word8 msb :: Int fromTwosComp :: Integral a => [Octet] -> a toOctets :: Integral a => a -> a -> [Octet] fromOctets :: Num a => a -> [Octet] -> a i2osp :: Integral a => Int -> a -> [Octet]
Thinking about it, i2osp should go in Codec.Encryption.RSA as it's specific to RSA.
I'm not clear about the rest. How about Codec.Integral for toOctets, fromOctets and fromTwosComp? I could probably live without Octet (although quite a few standards are defined using the term octet) but I find myself needing msb (most significant bit) in quite a few places. Where would that go?
If these really are general codec utilities, applicable to multiple codecs, then Codec.Utils is fine. There's no point trying too hard to categorise things.
OK, with the exception of i2osp, I'll leave them in Codec.Utils
Whilst on the subject, why is BER in Network? BER is one of many encodings for ASN.1 and use of BER is not limited to networks; it is used heavily in cryptography, for example, in PKCS#8 and X.509. I'd suggest Codec.ASN1.BER, Codec.ASN1.TLV for the functions that take octets and turn them into Tags, Lengths and Values and Codec.ASN1.ASN1 for real ASN.1 types and functions.
Ok, I'll add these. But Codec.ASN1.ASN1 looks a bit strange - why not just use Codec.ASN1?
Agreed.
Furthermore, if I follow the hierarchy for the existing cryptography library then I would end up with Data.Digest for MD5 and SHA-1. What would the package name for these be? Digest? What should the package name be for DES, AES, Blowfish and RSA be? Still crypto or Encryption?
You can choose any package names you like, as long as they're unique. Package names have no relationship to module names. When Hackage is up and running, you'll easily be able to find a new unique package name (for now, just pick one).
As an interim proposal, how about I put Data.LargeWord Data.Digest.MD5 Data.Digest.SHA-1 Codec.Encryption.RSA Codec.Encryption.RSA.EMEOAEP Codec.Encryption.RSA.MGF Codec.Encryption.RSA.NumberTheory Codec.Encryption.DES Codec.Encryption.AES Codec.Encryption.Blowfish Codec.Encryption.Modes Codec.Encryption.Padding Codec.Encryption.PKCS8 Codec.Encryption.X509 Codec.ASN1 Codec.ASN1.BER Codec.ASN1.TLV Codec.Utils into a package called Crypto? Dominic.
participants (2)
-
Dominic Steinitz -
Simon Marlow