On 2008.06.01 23:36:44 -0500, Spencer Janssen scribbled 1.2K characters:

On Sun, Jun 01, 2008 at 11:18:57PM -0500, Spencer Janssen wrote:

...

On Sun, Jun 01, 2008 at 06:27:18PM -0400, Gwern Branwen wrote:

...

Ho everyone:

I recently installed Ubuntu, and so could now use Amarok (the Gentoo installation being messed up for me), and all is well. I went to add a keybinding:

...

, ((m, xK_a), runOrRaise "amarok" (title =? "Amarok"))

And it is kind of odd. It is the correct name, and it works correctly when Amarok is not running - but if Amarok is running, it only causes a file dialogue to open up instead of the right thing. (See attached screenshots.)

Is this Amarok's fault? Any ideas how to work around it?

-- gwern FSK S511 Zemin Monica PABX NSG mercur text Meade ULF

Try matching on the WM_CLASS (note that it is set to "amarokapp") instead. If this works, there might be some problem with the 'title' function.

Very good advice, Spencer. I'd also add that Amarok changes title when music is playing, making it rather likely that this is not an issue with xmonad's 'title' function at all. WM_CLASS should be much more robust here since it is a violation of the ICCCM to change those properties after requesting that the window be mapped.

Yes, className "amarokapp" works fine. I asked because title to me was not failing in a familiar way - usually when I use 'title' and it fails, it is because the title has changed, and so title fails to find the existing app and it then falls through to the run part. It does not usually "sort of work" by bringing up some file dialogue! -- gwern sweeping Hitwords Intelsat Counter Cohiba Sayeret Rumsfeld VOA warfare encryption

On 2008.06.02 19:58:14 -0400, Xiao-Yong Jin scribbled 1.0K characters:

Gwern Branwen writes:

...

On 2008.06.01 23:36:44 -0500, Spencer Janssen scribbled 1.2K characters:

...

Very good advice, Spencer. I'd also add that Amarok changes title when music is playing, making it rather likely that this is not an issue with xmonad's 'title' function at all. WM_CLASS should be much more robust here since it is a violation of the ICCCM to change those properties after requesting that the window be mapped.

Yes, className "amarokapp" works fine. I asked because title to me was not failing in a familiar way - usually when I use 'title' and it fails, it is because the title has changed, and so title fails to find the existing app and it then falls through to the run part. It does not usually "sort of work" by bringing up some file dialogue!

If you try to run "amarok" from CLI while an instance of Amarok is running, you will see the open-file dialog.

Xiao-Yong

I tried that just now. When Amarok is running, a > /usr/bin/amarok just returns successfully. Perhaps the Ubuntu Heron Amarok is different from yours. -- gwern Ma Hindawi WID JTF-6 Gorizont BROMURE Submarine hitword ERR SORT