On Wed, 20 Jun 2007 06:54:58 -0700 David Roundy wrote:

Hi all,

Here's a moderate-sized change that might be controversial. I've replaced xineScreens with a screenLayout that calls into Xinerama to get the screen rectangles. This has a couple of potential advantages.

One is that we could use this to move the gap treatment into XMonadContrib, or at least out of XState, as we no longer require a special data structure to store the gaps: it could just be a very simple Layout modifier. I believe this would simplify the core even if we don't move it entirely into XMonadContrib (which is what I'd do, figuring that core should be only things that either everyone needs or are both trivially small and something that everyone needs *one* of.

It also (and this is why I wrote this) allows (with a separately sent XMonadContrib module) those of us who only have one screen to pretend we've got more than one screen. So all developers can test and see how things will behave (e.g. sticky-window code) under Xinerama. And it also gives users the ability to get something like a version of Combo that works with tabs, and sort of emulates sticky windows. I don't think it'd really a long-term solution to either of those UI goals, but in the interim, it's better than nothing. It might even be enough to get me to upgrade at work to the latest xmonad (I've been sticking with the one where Combo worked).

Anyhow, this is the first application of the more general Layout type. It expands the code a little bit, but if we use it to simplify gap handling, that might be enough to compensate.

David

P.S. To reiterate, I think that the ability to test Xinerama behavior easily is enough to make this patch worthwhile, particularly since that seems to be a primary goal of xmonad, and it makes it tricky for those of us who don't have that possibility to make changes to xmonad core that will be acceptable. e.g. many of us want sticky windows, but we hear that it'll be hard with Xinerama, but folks with multiple screens don't seem to care, presumably because they've already got sticky workspaces.

Wed Jun 20 06:36:03 PDT 2007 David Roundy * use a Layout to set the Screen rectangles. An accompanying patch will allow those of us with only one physical screen to divide it into virtual screens at runtime.

How about a simple contrib extension that modifies 'xineScreens' and windowSet to fit some user specified geometry? It's considerably simpler and requires no changes to xmonad itself. Spencer Janssen